Brick attached-home entrance with bluestone steps, tall windows, and a copper-red paperbark maple beside an autumn garden.

Madison's Next New Homes Are Coming From Two Campuses on Madison Avenue

Off Madison Avenue at Dodge Drive sits a 21.149-acre campus built for one office tenant. Mack-Cali developed 3 Giralda Farms, and Quest Diagnostics used it as a single-tenant headquarters. Under a plan Madison adopted this year, the campus can become up to 138 for-sale townhouses and stacked homes. Toll Brothers is named as the contract purchaser.

About a mile and a half east, also on Madison Avenue, Drew University is splitting its campus into separate lots. The split lets the borough buy the Drew Forest, and the same agreement sets two smaller parcels on a path toward multifamily housing.

These two sites are where Madison's new housing supply is taking shape. In both, the homes come out of the same deal that preserves land and counts toward the borough's affordable-housing obligations. That pairing decides what gets built, which is mostly attached and multifamily housing. In Morris County right now, that kind of home sells differently from the single-family houses most buyers picture when they think of Madison.

The Office Campus Is Zoned for Townhouses

The 3 Giralda Farms redevelopment plan allows up to 138 attached for-sale homes, either townhouses or stacked units:

  • 110 at market rate
  • 28 set aside as affordable, with at least four of those built as three-bedroom townhomes

Buildings are limited to three stories at the front entrance, with some four-story walkouts allowed at the rear. The developer must also set aside at least 3.5 acres of connected open space next to Chatham Township's Giralda Farms Preserve.

The plan moved through Madison's boards quickly once hearings began. TAPinto Madison reported that the Planning Board opened its hearing Feb. 3, 2026, and carried it over because public discussion wasn't finished. On Feb. 17, the board voted 8–0 to send the plan back to the Borough Council. Some residents at that hearing questioned the design and how it would look. Others spoke in favor of the open-space set-aside, affordable ownership and a wider mix of housing. The council gave final approval to Ordinance 15-2026 on March 23, 2026.

The adopted plan sets the rules for the site, and a specific project still needs its own site plan approval from the Planning Board. In July, the borough's Sustainable Madison Advisory Committee recorded that the Toll Brothers project "is advancing to the Planning Board" and that roughly 230 trees are proposed for removal. At its Sept. 24 meeting, the Madison Environmental Commission listed the Toll Brothers development under site plan review as "Awaiting submission."

Next door, the 24.3-acre 1 Giralda Farms property is already further along. Its plan calls for multifamily housing on part of the site and a 52-bed supportive-housing development on the rest. On Aug. 4, 2026, the Planning Board memorialized its approval of the Madison Housing application for 1 Giralda Farms by a vote of 7–0. Amendments to the redeveloper agreements with R&O Madison Urban Renewal, LLC, and BCUW/Madeline Housing Partners, LLC, were on the council's Sept. 28 agenda.

The Forest Purchase Opens Eight Acres on the Drew Campus

Drew University and the borough announced their agreement on Jan. 12, 2026. Under it, Madison buys the 47.3-acre Drew Forest Preserve and the Madison House property. Drew sells other surplus land for "multi-family, inclusionary residential housing." Drew's announcement says the forest and the Zuck Arboretum help recharge the Buried Valley Aquifer and give the public access to about 22 acres of trails.

The purchase is funded from several sources. State Senator Anthony M. Bucco credited $9 million in state funding. The Friends of the Drew Forest set a $5 million private fundraising goal to complete the purchase. In the same announcement, Mayor Robert Conley said:

"It will be the commitment of generous donors of today that will complete the deal to save the forest for generations to come."

The borough's ordinance archive lists Ordinance 32-2026, a bond ordinance that sets aside $23.8 million to buy the Drew Forest property.

That purchase is tied directly to new housing. On Aug. 18, 2026, the Planning Board voted 6–0 to divide the roughly 163.92-acre campus at 36 Madison Avenue into five lots. Two lots cover the Drew Forest, one the Zuck Arboretum, one Madison House, and the last holds the remaining campus of about 114.938 acres. The housing parcels are two separate pieces of the campus proposed for subdivision, which a borough report identifies as Lots B and C:

  • Lot B covers 4.492 acres on the east side of Campus Drive, behind Madison United Methodist Church. It includes Lewis House and Sitterly House, faculty offices and parking.
  • Lot C covers 3.877 acres on the east side of Vinal Place, reached from Lancaster Road. It includes the Carriage House soccer field, a community garden and parking.

The borough's July 13 investigation report finds that both parcels meet the state's criteria for a non-condemnation area in need of redevelopment. It describes them as "proposed to be subdivided from the campus for future development, as part of a settlement agreement and the Borough's Housing Element & Fair Share Plan." The report was on the Planning Board's Oct. 6, 2026 agenda as new business.

Why New Housing Comes Bundled With Preserved Land

Madison's affordable-housing obligations, laid out in its Housing Element & Fair Share Plan, shape both deals. The 3 Giralda plan says its 28 affordable for-sale units help meet a separate court-ordered Third Round obligation of 77 units. For the Fourth Round, a borough presentation puts Madison's prospective need at 206 units. After adjusting for how much land can realistically be developed, that falls to an obligation of 56.

In a borough with little vacant land, the most realistic places for new homes are large parcels held by one owner that is ready to change how it uses them. An office campus whose single tenant has left and a university with surplus land both fit. Each owner gets a sale and each site gets rezoned. In return, the borough secures preserved acreage and affordable units it has to provide anyway. That is why the open-space set-aside and the inclusionary units appear in the same documents as the market-rate homes.

Site Land What the plans allow Latest recorded step
3 Giralda Farms 21.149 acres, former Quest campus Up to 138 for-sale attached homes, 28 of them affordable Plan adopted March 23; site plan listed as awaiting submission Sept. 24
1 Giralda Farms 24.3 acres Multifamily plus 52-bed supportive housing Approval memorialized Aug. 4
Drew Lots B and C 8.369 acres combined Multifamily inclusionary housing under the settlement Redevelopment study on Oct. 6 Planning Board agenda
Drew Forest Preserve 47.3 acres Borough purchase and preservation $23.8 million bond ordinance listed

The New Homes Are a Different Product, and That Changes the Price Math

None of the new homes on these sites are planned as detached single-family houses. They'll be townhouses, stacked units and apartments, and in Morris County that kind of home currently sells on different terms.

The NJ REALTORS® Morris County report for September 2026 shows the gap:

  • Single-family: 306 closed sales at a median of $737,500, with sellers receiving 104.0% of list price.
  • Townhouses and condos: 79 closed sales at a median of $540,000, with sellers receiving 99.2% of list price.

Both segments were tight that month. Townhouses and condos had 2.2 months of supply, slightly less than the 2.5 months for single-family homes. Even so, attached homes sold just under list price while single-family homes sold above it. Short supply alone isn't producing bidding wars in the attached segment. These are countywide figures, not Madison's, but they show which market the Giralda and Drew homes will join.

A buyer comparing Madison with nearby towns is looking at two markets. Single-family resales follow the countywide pattern of offers above list. The coming attached supply falls in the segment where the countywide pattern is sales close to list.

If 138 for-sale townhouses arrive on Madison Avenue, Madison's attached segment will be larger than it is today. In September 2026, the Morris County townhouse-and-condo median was about $197,500 below the single-family median.

Milestones Between Now and a Listing

Each site has public milestones still ahead of any sale:

  1. 3 Giralda Farms site plan. The Toll Brothers site plan has to be submitted and approved. Under the adopted plan, details like the trail connection to the Giralda Farms Preserve are set in the site plan the Planning Board approves. The roughly 230 trees proposed for removal are likely to come up in that review.
  2. Lots B and C designation. The Oct. 6 investigation report is the first formal step. A redevelopment plan for the two Drew parcels would follow, setting unit counts and building heights.
  3. Drew Forest closing. The bond ordinance and the Friends of the Drew Forest campaign are the pieces that complete the purchase. The forest purchase and the Lots B and C housing are part of the same settlement.
  4. 1 Giralda Farms agreements. The Sept. 28 council agenda shows the redeveloper agreements are still being amended after site plan approval.

FAQ

Are the 3 Giralda Farms homes for sale or for rent? The adopted plan allows for-sale attached homes: up to 110 at market rate and 28 affordable.

Does the Drew Forest purchase stop development on campus? No. It preserves the 47.3-acre forest, and the same settlement provides for multifamily inclusionary housing on other surplus Drew land.

Who qualifies for the affordable units? The adopted 3 Giralda Farms plan sets out the affordable units and how they count toward Madison's obligations. This post is general information, not legal or financial advice, so please confirm any eligibility questions directly with the Borough of Madison or a qualified professional.

If you're weighing a Madison single-family home against a Giralda Farms townhouse, or wondering how the new supply could affect a sale you're planning, Godby Realtors follows these Madison Avenue projects through each step. We can walk you through how both markets are pricing today and what to watch as approvals move forward. Request a Concierge Consultation.

Work With Us

Godby Real Estate is a privately owned full service real estate company serving Morris and surrounding counties. Satisfied customers are our greatest asset!

Follow Us on Instagram